My position

Solidarity with Palestine is not a crime

Why I defend people prosecuted for their solidarity with Palestine

I am an anti-fascist. I stand for protecting Jewish life, in Germany and everywhere in the world. Antisemitism is no more acceptable to me than anti-Muslim racism or any other form of discrimination based on origin, religion or affiliation.

Because of its history, Germany bears a particular responsibility towards Jews. The Nazis' policy of extermination and the murder of six million European Jews create a historical obligation that will never end.

But that responsibility is not exclusive. Nazi Germany's crimes also create a particular obligation towards international law, which applies universally, not only when it fits a political agenda. The obligation towards Jews must not result in injustice suffered by other people being relativised, let alone justified.

Israel's history cannot be understood without the history of European antisemitism, and particularly the German crimes of National Socialism.

Israel became a homeland and refuge for Jews who had been persecuted in Europe for centuries and finally exterminated on an industrial scale. But the land in which the Jewish state emerged was not empty. Palestinians had lived there for centuries: a predominantly Arab population of Muslim and Christian faith in what was then British Mandate Palestine.

The establishment of Israel in 1948 and the preceding war were accompanied by the Nakba: the flight and expulsion of around 700,000 Palestinians from their homeland. Many of their descendants still live as refugees in neighbouring Lebanon, Jordan or Syria, or under occupation in Gaza and the West Bank.

Germany does not bear sole responsibility for this historic conflict. But its history is inseparable from the conditions under which the State of Israel emerged.

For me, this has a political, legal and moral consequence: Germany's responsibility towards Jewish people must not be played off against Palestinians' rights. It is not only the Jewish people who have a right to freedom, security and self-determination, but the Palestinian people too.

Those who derive a particular obligation to protect Israel from German history are right. But they must not disregard the Palestinians' expulsion, disenfranchisement and oppression in doing so.

The safety of Jewish people and the freedom of Palestinians are not opposites.

Peoples' right to self-determination is one of the fundamental principles of international law.

The United Nations General Assembly has repeatedly recognised the legitimacy of struggles against colonial rule, foreign domination and occupation. Under certain conditions, that includes armed resistance.

This does not, of course, give violence a free pass. Armed resistance too is subject to international humanitarian law. Attacks on civilians, hostage-taking, torture and other war crimes are prohibited. None of that is open to relativisation.

On 7 October 2023, Israeli civilians were murdered and abducted as hostages. No right of resistance can justify these acts.

But 7 October did not consist exclusively of attacks on civilians. Israeli border installations, military bases and military forces were also attacked.

Distinctions under international law instead of blanket judgements

A distinction is also required regarding captives. Capturing enemy soldiers in an armed conflict is not in itself hostage-taking. Whether hostage-taking in violation of international law has occurred depends on the specific circumstances. Not everyone detained in connection with an armed conflict is legally a hostage. This applies regardless of which side of the conflict they are on. Palestinians held by Israel in administrative detention, sometimes for years without criminal conviction, are not described as Israel's hostages merely because they are detained either.

These distinctions are essential under international law. Deliberately killing a civilian must be assessed differently from attacking a soldier who constitutes a lawful military target in an armed conflict.

Whether a particular attack was lawful must be assessed under international humanitarian law and the actual circumstances. Especially where criminal proceedings concern approving such acts, that examination must not be replaced by a blanket judgement of the entire event.

Insisting on these distinctions does not justify crimes against civilians. It means insisting on the application of international law.

I refuse to treat 7 October as one legally undifferentiated event in which any expression of support for armed resistance is automatically understood as approval of terrorism.

Nor is it acceptable to portray 7 October as an act of ultimate evil and mention it in the same breath as the Holocaust.

In Germany, debate over the Middle East conflict is increasingly shaped by a concept of antisemitism whose scope is itself contested in academic and political discussion.

The working definition adopted by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) includes examples of Israel-related antisemitism whose application results in legitimate criticism of Israeli state policy being classified as antisemitic.

The Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism offers a different approach. It expressly distinguishes hostility towards Jews from political positions on Israel, Zionism and Palestinian self-determination.

I consider this distinction indispensable.

Anyone condemning Israeli occupation policy, denouncing the expulsion of Palestinians, describing Israel as an apartheid state or calling for a boycott of Israeli products is not automatically an antisemite for that reason.

The demand for equal political rights for everyone between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean is not inherently antisemitic either.

Questioning the State of Israel as a Zionist project and advocating an equal, democratic one-state solution is likewise not antisemitic.

Israel is not a religiously protected object beyond political criticism. The State of Israel, its government, army and state institutions must be measured against the same standards of international law as every other state.

Since 7 October 2023, numerous criminal proceedings in Germany have targeted people publicly expressing solidarity with Palestine.

These concern, among other things, demonstrations, slogans, social media posts and statements about 7 October.

In particular, section 140 StGB, the provision criminalising approval of offences, raises serious questions.

Not every positive reference to Palestinian resistance amounts to approval of murder, hostage-taking or a terrorist attack on civilians. Nevertheless, political security units seem to display a knee-jerk aggressive response as soon as supposed approval of terrorist offences is at issue.

A criminal conviction requires the statutory elements of the offence to be met. This includes establishing which specific unlawful act was approved and whether the statement was capable of disturbing public peace.

Political disapproval of a statement is no substitute for that examination.

Nor may a contested definition of antisemitism become the basis for interpreting criminal law.

Freedom of expression does not protect only moderate, majority-approved and politically welcome opinions. It particularly protects sharp, provocative and uncomfortable political positions too.

A state that lets its citizens speak freely only as long as they share its foreign policy positions has not understood the purpose of freedom of expression.

I do not defend people because I share every political conviction they hold. Criminal defence does not require identification with a client or their actions.

But I decide for myself which side I stand on.

I stand with those who oppose oppression, occupation, expulsion and disenfranchisement. I stand for freedom of expression and the right to political opposition.

That is why I defend people prosecuted in Germany for their solidarity with Palestine, their statements or their actions – whether rightly or wrongly.

In particular, I will challenge the equation of criticism of Israeli state crimes with antisemitism, and the treatment of support for Palestinian self-determination as approval of terrorist offences.

Political prosecutions do not affect only people who can afford an elaborate defence.

They affect students, young activists, people on low incomes and those for whom even the cost of an initial legal consultation is a considerable burden.

They, in particular, need an effective defence.

Anyone prosecuted over allegations connected with solidarity with Palestine who cannot afford a lawyer can contact me. In these cases, I offer a free initial consultation – and, where needed, take on the defence free of charge (pro bono) as well.

Fundamental rights must not depend on whether someone can afford to defend them.

Get in touch →