Juvenile criminal law as a political battleground

Juvenile criminal law

Young people are not miniature adults.

Young people often act more spontaneously, think less far ahead and are more easily carried away by their friends, the moment or a bad idea. That this can also result in crime is about as surprising as rain in November.

Even Aristotle recognised that young people think differently from mature adults.

‘As for young people, their desires are intense, and they are inclined to put into practice whatever they desire.’

Aristotle, philosopher, quoted from bildungswissenschaftler.de

Behaviour typical of youth existed before anyone invented a situation report for it. That is precisely why juvenile criminal law treats young people differently from adults — an old insight that is nevertheless regularly rediscovered, even though the Youth Courts Act (JGG) is already over a century old, having entered into force on 1 July 1923.

The Federal Chancellor, who readily justifies crimes against international law as necessary ‘dirty work’ when committed by allied Israelis and Americans, plays the tough guy when ordinary people commit offences:

‘Well, I have absolutely no understanding for discussing voting rights at 16 while the age of criminal responsibility for young people is between 18 and 21.’

Federal Chancellor Friedrich Merz (also known as ‘Lying Fritz’) in WELT

Merz thereby lumps a small number of young offenders together with a large number of law-abiding young people.

Of course, it would not occur to him to link adult tax evaders to their voting rights, or to question tax evaders' right to vote. As so often, this reveals a lack of political understanding:

Harsher penalties often actually increase reoffending

There is broad agreement in criminology, developmental psychology and neuroscience that demands for harsher penalties for young people, such as longer prison sentences or lowering the age of criminal responsibility, have no behaviour-changing or deterrent effect.

Empirical studies and justice-system reoffending statistics instead demonstrate the opposite: Harsher penalties often actually increase reoffending. The main reasons fall into six criminological and neurobiological categories:

1. Neurobiology: the brain's developmental phase

  • Lack of impulse control: The human brain does not fully mature until the mid-twenties. The prefrontal cortex, responsible for logical thought, weighing consequences and self-control, develops last.
  • The pull of the reward system: In young people, the limbic system, the emotional and reward centre, is particularly active. Offences usually happen spontaneously, through high spirits, group pressure or alcohol. At those moments, there is no rational weighing-up of potential sentences.

2. The mistaken assumption behind deterrence theory

  • The likelihood of arrest and detection matters: Criminological research shows that the deterrent is not the severity of the threatened punishment, but the risk of getting caught.
  • No knowledge of the law: Very few young offenders know the precise sentencing range under juvenile criminal law. A higher maximum sentence therefore simply has no influence on the decision-making process before an offence.

3. The ‘prison effect’ (School of Crime)

  • Social uprooting: Locking young people up tears them out of protective social structures such as school, training, sports clubs and family.
  • Negative peer groups: In custody, young offenders meet other prolific offenders. They adopt criminal patterns of behaviour and values, a ‘prison-cell subculture’, which greatly increases the likelihood of reoffending.

4. Developmental delinquency (the episodic principle)

  • Episodic character: Much youth crime is so-called ‘episodic misconduct’, such as shoplifting, minor criminal damage or dares.
  • Self-regulation: Long-term criminological studies, such as Münster University's Crimocstudy, show that most young people stop offending as they mature without any state intervention. Excessively harsh interventions can even disrupt this natural process and entrench criminal identities.

5. The problem of stigma (Labelling Approach)

  • Being labelled a ‘criminal’: When a young person is sentenced early and harshly, the label of the prosecuted person often becomes part of their self-image.
  • Future prospects: A criminal record or time in custody makes entering the labour market and reintegration into society considerably harder, paving the way towards persistent offending.

6. Failure to address causes

  • Penalties target the symptoms rather than the causes of youth crime, such as neglect, violence at home, drug problems, mental disorders or educational disadvantage. A prison term does not solve an addiction or violence problem; it often makes it worse.

What criminology says works instead

MeasureWhy it works
A swift responseA prompt consequence following an offence, reflecting the educational principle, is more effective than a heavy penalty after months of court delays.
Diversion & victim–offender mediationConfronting the victim and making amends, for example through community work or an apology, promotes a genuine understanding of wrongdoing more than custody.
Educational measuresAnti-violence training, addiction counselling and supervised respite accommodation address the real causes of delinquency.
Intensive social workSupporting families and reintegrating young people into education or training are the most effective ways to prevent reoffending.

Fortunately, most youth court judges are wiser than the Federal Chancellor.

That is why not every youth court trial over a minor matter requires an experienced criminal defence lawyer, especially where the offence is established or admitted.

That certainly does not apply to everyone. And:

In particular, where the defence seeks an acquittal, a criminal defence lawyer is indispensable: nothing damages a young person's sense of justice more than being pressured into a false confession by a youth judge holding out great leniency for confessing and a harsh youth sentence for denial.

Or where political convictions prompted the conduct and the young person does not want to apologise for them.

I also take juvenile cases as court-appointed defence counsel. The state treasury pays court-appointed defence costs; they are not imposed on young people. Where no counsel is appointed, I discuss with you how a defence can nevertheless be arranged.

Facing juvenile criminal proceedings?

+49 172 7224081