The nature of criminal defence
Anyone who is a defence lawyer must know that they will not be loved.
Max Alsberg, one of the Weimar Republic's most renowned criminal defence lawyers
The criminal defence lawyer
‘He is in conflict with state power, with public sentiment, often with the press and usually with the court. To the public, he can easily appear an accomplice of the criminal; to the judge, an irritating obstacle to finding the truth; to the prosecution, the natural enemy.
He must have a heart that beats for humanity even where it has fallen; a mind that is sharp even where reason fails; a tongue that speaks where others remain silent; a back that is strong where others bow.
Whoever has all this and is nevertheless prepared to reap the proverbial ingratitude of his country and his clients every day – that person is born to be a defence lawyer.’
So said Max Alsberg (1877–1933) in his famous lecture ‘The Philosophy of the Defence’. There is little to add – except perhaps that the police officer, too, regards the criminal defence lawyer as a natural enemy. And that is what he is, at least if he takes his job seriously.
What general criminal law involves
General criminal law is the foundation of my daily work. It covers all the traditional allegations arising in everyday life, at work and on the road – from theft, fraud and breach of trust to assault, coercion and insult, through to forgery, criminal damage and road traffic offences.
For those affected, a criminal investigation is often an exceptional crisis. The police and prosecution enjoy a considerable advantage in knowledge and power – and use it. My job is to establish equality of arms.
How I defend:
- Protect your silence, examine the file: No statement before full access to the case file. We decide on a strategy only once we know what the investigating authorities actually have.
- Intervene early: The best criminal proceedings are those that never reach court. Wherever possible, I work towards a discreet discontinuance during the investigation.
- Fight consistently: If a trial cannot be avoided, I defend using every means available under the Code of Criminal Procedure – calmly, precisely and without undue regard for the court's desire for a quiet life.
Alongside general criminal law, my particular areas of focus are: