The nature of state force

When the monopoly on force becomes a one-way street: police violence and the mechanics of the counter-allegation.

Why unlawful assaults by officials disappear from view, and counter-allegations act as a systemic shield.

The state's monopoly on force is the foundation of domestic security. Yet in criminal practice it acquires an asymmetrical impact that makes a mockery of due process. While offences against police officers are prosecuted with impressive statistical precision, unlawful police violence disappears into a deep blind spot of discontinued proceedings, collegial loyalty and systemic difficulties of proof.

The statistical phantom: section 340 StGB in the blind spot

Official justice statistics recorded 2,790 completed prosecutorial investigations against police officers for unlawful use of force in 2021. At first sight, a substantial number. But looking at the outcomes reveals the reality: prosecutors discontinue over 90 per cent of cases – usually for lack of sufficient grounds for suspicion. Only around two per cent lead to an indictment.

The unrecorded cases revealed by the KviAPol project's criminological research paint an even starker picture: only nine per cent of the affected people surveyed reported the incident. Criminal proceedings followed in 14 per cent of the cases described. The low willingness to report also reflects a rational calculation: those affected know how slim their prospects are against the united testimony of officers.

The counter-allegation as a systemic shield

Even more serious than simple under-recording is the potential reversal of the perpetrator–victim relationship. When police operations involve physical force and injuries, an allegation of police violence is often followed by a report alleging resistance to enforcement officers under section 113 StGB or a physical attack under section 114 StGB. In the KviAPol survey, 65 per cent of those who had themselves filed a complaint were in turn reported by the police.

This reveals a remarkable legislative imbalance: while section 340 StGB (assault in public office) provides for a standard minimum prison sentence of three months, but already in subsection 1 allows for a less serious case with a possible fine, section 114 StGB contains no such less serious case. A physical attack ordinarily also carries a minimum prison sentence of three months. Section 113 StGB, by contrast, can carry a fine even in an ordinary case.

Given the broad interpretation of force in case law, merely pulling an arm away or bracing oneself during a scuffle may become the subject of an allegation of resistance or assault. Whether the conduct actually meets the requirements of sections 113 or 114 StGB must be examined individually. In practice, a counter-allegation can turn a citizen from victim into accused. In competing proceedings, the KviAPol study describes a tendency to discontinue allegations of assault in public office when the facts are unclear, while being more inclined to indict for resistance.

The task of criminal defence

Effective criminal defence in this area requires more than meticulous file analysis. It demands the courage to challenge official self-serving accounts, critically examine witness testimony and expose structural ties between investigating authorities and the police.

Anyone wishing to preserve the state's monopoly on force must not trivialise unlawful overstepping by officials. Where the state protects its own agencies from a thorough investigation, trust in the rule of law erodes at its most sensitive point.

Affected by police violence or facing a counter-allegation?

+49 172 7224081